The 7 Best Resorts in Harbour Island Bahamas – 2025 Update
We picked the best resorts on Harbour Island that offer something truly unforgettable. Top-tier service, beautiful beaches, and great food and drinks are all included at these highest rated properties.
That said, this little Bahamian escape—known for its powdery soft pink-sand shoreline and easygoing charm—happens to be packed with getaways that are, frankly, just a little more polished than your typical tropical destination.
Table of Contents
Methodology
To figure out the best resorts Harbour Island has to offer, we read and reviewed all the reviews from actual people who’ve stayed at these Harbour Island Bahamas resorts before.
We focused mostly on user experiences from sites like Google Reviews, Booking.com, TripAdvisor, and Expedia—because, let’s face it, travelers don’t hold back when things go sideways.
We looked at how people talked about the resort vibe, beach access, room quality, food and drink, service levels, and even how the pools and views made them feel.
Please note that some links below are affiliate links, which means that we receive a small commission if you make a purchase through our links, but at no extra cost to you. Thank you in advance for your support!
The 7 Best Resorts in Harbour Island Bahamas for 2025
7. Romora Bay Resort & Marina
Key Highlights:
- 4 acres of breezy waterfront property with unobstructed sunset views
- Over 40 marina slips with personalized boat assistance
- Infinity-edge pool positioned right on the waterline
This boutique marina getaway tends to be a little less crowded than the others, yet it’s got this slightly upscale boating club energy that works surprisingly well.
The guest spaces are pretty comfortable, with warmly styled interiors that, honestly, feel more like a coastal condo than a hotel room. There’s usually a balcony or patio involved, which helps with the whole relaxed island vibe.
Romora Bay is not just a resort—it’s also a marina, and that’s what makes it one of the more unique Harbour Island Bahamas resorts, especially for folks arriving by sea.
It’s almost like your yacht or catamaran becomes an extension of your stay, which is kind of cool in its own right.
The pool area sits right up against the water and, in fact, feels like it melts into the harbor at sunset. Sunset Bar & Grille handles on-site dining and the seafood tends to be fresh, flavorful, and generously portioned, too.
Golf carts are available for exploring, and you’re just a short ride from Pink Sand Beach and small shops. It’s not super kid-focused, but for adult travelers who like ocean breezes and fewer distractions, this resort works very well.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
6. Tingum Village Hotel – Most Affordable
Key Highlights:
- One of the most budget-friendly Harbour Island resorts
- Roughly a 3-minute walk to Pink Sand Beach
- Cozy on-site eatery with hearty local food options
This family-run stay feels, in a way, like visiting a cousin’s comfy beach house—if that cousin just happened to be a Bahamian innkeeper with a knack for hospitality.
The rooms are simple, for sure, but they tend to be colorful and surprisingly roomy. It’s one of those Harbour Island resorts where you spend most of your time out and about, but when you crash for the night, you’ve got everything you need—kitchenettes, patios, and air-conditioning included.
Location-wise, you’re almost closer to Pink Sand Beach than some of the luxury resorts, and that proximity is definitely a perk. They even offer beach gear to borrow, which is nice for folks trying to keep things light and breezy.
The hotel has a small restaurant that feels like a neighborhood café, and they serve up hearty local food—think cracked conch and plantains. Also, it’s pet-friendly and good for families, so that’s kind of a bonus you don’t see everywhere on the island.
So, while it’s clearly not a high-end resort, Tingum Village is one of the more budget-friendly Harbour Island Bahamas resorts that still checks off most boxes.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
5. Eleven Bahama House
Key Highlights:
- Just 11 rooms with individually designed interiors
- Daily sunset cocktails and tailored excursions included
- Quiet location close to the beach and central harbor
Eleven Bahama House is an incredibly private, yet centrally located resort, and the building itself is an old estate that’s been revamped into a sleek boutique resort.
Each room has this distinct personality, and most come with little perks like outdoor showers or garden patios.
The small pool is perfect for cooling off, and the leafy courtyard is a great place to unwind. In a way, it’s less about amenities here and more about the curated experience—staff will help plan your activities, book meals, and even set up private boat rides or snorkeling trips nearby.
There’s no restaurant right on the property, but the team works with top local chefs and eateries, which honestly gives you more variety.
It’s basically ideal for couples, friend groups, or solo travelers who want a high-end experience that’s not too stuffy or over-the-top.
So if you’re into quiet luxury and service that feels more like a lifestyle manager than a front desk clerk, this might be your spot.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
4. The Dunmore Hotel & Resort
Key Highlights:
- Smack on the famous Pink Sand Beach
- 25 upscale cottages and villas with coastal decor
- Oceanview restaurant, wellness spa, and full-service pool
It’s hard not to immediately notice how effortlessly classic The Dunmore feels. It’s got this old-school Bahamian flair mixed with updated comfort that people genuinely appreciate.
The rooms—mostly standalone cottages—are airy, softly designed, and well-spaced, and many include porches that face the ocean or gardens. It’s quiet, but not boring, and very easy to navigate, which makes it a good fit for both couples and families with older kids.
The pool is sleek, surrounded by tropical greenery, and just steps from the beach, so you’re never far from a place to lounge.
Dining at the resort’s restaurant feels elevated without being too formal, and the seafood-forward menu tends to rotate depending on what’s fresh and in season.
Because the property sits directly on Pink Sand Beach, the walk from your room to the water takes all of 30 seconds, which is definitely a highlight. The resort also has golf carts, a tennis court, and optional spa treatments, making it one of the most well-rounded Harbour Island resorts.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
3. Valentines Resort And Marina – Top Value Pick
Key Highlights:
- Spacious 1–3-bedroom luxury suites with kitchens
- Fully-equipped dive center and 50+ slip marina
- Just a few minutes from Pink Sand Beach by foot
This resort blends the best parts of a high-end stay with the utility of a full apartment setup, which tends to work well for longer vacations or family trips.
Suites at Valentines feel more like condos—bright kitchens, washer-dryer units, separate living areas—so you can really spread out. It’s fairly uncommon to find Harbour Island Bahamas resorts with that much in-room space without a jaw-dropping price tag.
There’s a nice big pool in the center of the property, along with an on-site coffee shop and a seafood restaurant that stays fairly busy most evenings.
Plus, the dive center is a huge bonus for anyone wanting to explore the reefs, go spearfishing, or try snorkeling without much hassle.
The marina out front attracts quite a few boating guests, which adds to the social vibe. That makes Valentines Resort And Marina one of the best Harbour Island resorts in terms of value and location, especially if you’re someone who likes doing more than just lying around all day.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
2. Pink Sands Resort
Key Highlights:
- Sprawling across 20+ beachfront acres
- Spacious private cottages and villas available
- Direct beach access with chairs, umbrellas, and service
Pink Sands Resort is more or less a peaceful retreat tucked into a giant garden that just so happens to spill out onto one of the most stunning beaches in the Caribbean.
Each cottage or villa is uniquely positioned, giving guests this wonderful sense of privacy and space. Interiors usually feature breezy layouts, soft tones, and big windows to keep things bright and beachy.
There’s also a spa, wellness options, yoga classes, and a beachfront restaurant called Blue Bar where you can eat dinner as the sky turns into a painting.
So, in that case, it’s pretty clear why this resort remains one of the most talked-about Harbour Island Bahamas resorts around.
It’s very well suited for romantic getaways or anyone who just needs to truly unplug and slow things down for a bit. Plus, it’s pet-friendly and kid-friendly, which is kind of rare for a resort this upscale.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
1. Rock House Hotel – Top Overall
Key Highlights:
- Adults-only retreat with 10 high-end suites
- Infinity pool with panoramic bay views
- Located in the heart of Dunmore Town, walkable to nightlife
Rock House Hotel hits that sweet spot where stylish meets laid-back, and it does so with an adults-only setup that’s both exclusive and incredibly relaxed.
There are only ten rooms, each one styled like a mix between a colonial Caribbean home and a luxury beach villa. It’s clearly for travelers who want peace and sophistication without being totally cut off from local flavor.
The infinity pool is probably one of the prettiest on the island, and the views stretch out across the bay like something out of a movie.
The restaurant is upscale but unpretentious, and guests usually end up dining there most nights without even planning to.
Because it’s so centrally located, you’re within walking distance of shops, cafes, and bars—but still tucked away just enough to feel like you’re somewhere secluded. If you’re looking for the best resort in Harbour Island Bahamas that nails pretty much every detail, Rock House is that spot.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
Articles You Might Also Like
