7 Best Key West Beachfront Resorts in 2025 | Right on the Sand
We did all the research and found the best Key West beachfront resorts that are located directly on the sand so that you can get guaranteed beach access during your trip to Florida’s version of paradise.
When people start dreaming up their next island getaway, they often picture resorts in Key West on the beach. The destination tends to be a little bit different from the rest of Florida, with its laid-back vibe, crystal-clear shoreline, and that unmistakable mix of history and tropical charm.
But, of course, not every place to stay sits directly on the waterfront, and honestly, some just stretch the definition of a “beachfront” resort. So, this list is focused on finding Key West resorts with beaches.
Table of Contents
How We Picked These Resorts
To determine the best Key West beachfront resorts, we spent hours digging through guest reviews, while also using Google Earth to double-check locations, and making sure every spot on this list actually is on the beach—no long treks or awkward detours required.
In other words, we focused on Key West resorts with beaches that don’t just claim oceanfront views but actually deliver the full experience with a sandy patch of shoreline directly connected to their property.
That means private beaches (when possible), direct access to the water, and the kind of amenities that make a vacation feel seamless. In short, if you’re looking for the best resort in Key West with beach access, this list is where you’ll find it.
Please note that some links below are affiliate links, which means that we receive a small commission if you make a purchase through our links, but at no extra cost to you. Thank you in advance for your support!
The 7 Best Resorts in Key West with Beaches
7. Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton
Google Reviews Score: 3.6 out of 5.0
Key Highlights:
- Private stretch of sandy shoreline spanning 1,100 feet
- Two oceanfront swimming pools with cabana service
- Historic architecture with modern upgrades
The Casa Marina Key West has been around for more than a century, and that historic charm is pretty much baked into the experience.
It’s one of those Key West beachfront resorts that has an old-money, vintage glam feel, yet at the same time, it still manages to have modern comforts.
That being said, it has a bit of a reputation for mixed reviews—some guests love the timeless atmosphere, while others think it’s due for more updates.
As for the actual beach, it’s one of the largest private stretches of sand in Key West, which is a big deal since a lot of properties don’t have much shoreline to work with.
The pools are set right on the water, so you get those uninterrupted ocean views. Meanwhile, many rooms open directly onto the beachfront as well.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
6. The Reach Key West, Curio Collection by Hilton
Google Reviews Score: 3.9 out of 5.0
Key Highlights:
- Situated directly on Key West’s only natural sand beach
- Newly renovated modern-style rooms
- On-site signature restaurant with ocean views
The Reach Key West is the slightly more polished Hilton sister property to Casa Marina.
This resort is often talked about because it has one of the few naturally occurring beaches on the island. That means you’re not dealing with artificially imported sand—what you get is the real deal, making it one of the top options for resorts in Key West on the beach.
Rooms are to be sleek and modern, with a bit more of an upscale feel than some of the older properties in town.
Additionally, the pool sits in a prime location right next to the water. Plus, with an on-site restaurant serving up fresh seafood and island-inspired dishes, you don’t have to venture far for a solid meal.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
5. Margaritaville Beach House Key West – Top Budget-Friendly Pick
Google Reviews Score: 4.1 out of 5.0
Key Highlights:
- Laid-back atmosphere with island-inspired decor
- Large pool surrounded by tropical landscaping
- Across the street from Smathers Beach
For those who aren’t looking to drop a small fortune on a beachfront stay, this resort is often the answer. The Margaritaville Beach House Key West is more about fun, relaxed vibes than ultra-luxury.
Since it’s across the street from Smathers Beach, you still get easy access to the ocean.
The resort itself leans into the whole island-life aesthetic, with bright colors, tropical patterns, and a general sense that you should probably be sipping something fruity at all times.
There’s a pool set amid lush greenery, and while the dining options are more casual, they do a solid job of delivering the kind of food you want on a warm, breezy day.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
4. Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa – Best-Seller
Google Reviews Score: 4.4 out of 5.0
Key Highlights:
- Waterfront infinity pool overlooking the Gulf
- Full-service spa offering ocean-inspired treatments
- Walking distance to Duval Street
The Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa is a popular pick for travelers who want a mix of beachfront relaxation and easy access to nightlife.
Unlike some properties that feel a bit tucked away, this one puts you within walking distance of Duval Street’s bars and restaurants.
The rooms are modern and comfortable, with balconies that let you take in that ocean breeze. There’s a spa on-site, an infinity pool that faces the water, and a solid mix of activities if you’re looking to do more than just lounge in the sun.
With all of these amenities, it’s easy to see why it’s one of the most booked resorts in Key West on the beach.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
3. Coconut Beach Resort
Google Reviews Score: 4.5 out of 5.0
Key Highlights:
- Intimate boutique setting with private beachfront
- Limited number of rooms for a more secluded feel
- Peaceful atmosphere away from the crowds
Unlike some of the bigger names on this list, Coconut Beach Resort is more of a hidden gem. It’s small, quiet, and, in some ways, feels like your own little pocket of paradise.
The rooms are limited in number, which means the property never feels overly crowded.
Therefore, it’s the kind of property that’s perfect for people who want to avoid the big-resort energy but still have that oceanfront experience.
The best part is that the beach is private, while the pool is surrounded by tropical landscaping, and the whole place feels like it belongs in a postcard.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
2. Sunset Key Cottages – Most Exclusive
Google Reviews Score: 4.6 out of 5.0
Key Highlights:
- Secluded private island accessible only by ferry
- Elegant beachfront cottages with wraparound porches
- Gourmet dining, full-service spa, and concierge-arranged activities
The Sunset Key Cottages is, without a doubt, the resort for travelers who want an ultra-luxurious experience on their own private island.
This retreat isn’t even on Key West itself—it’s tucked away on its own island, reachable only by a short ferry ride from the mainland. That in itself sets the tone for what’s essentially a next-level, away-from-the-crowds type of vacation.
The accommodations are anything but standard hotel rooms. Instead, you get beautifully designed private cottages, some that sit right along the beach, offering direct access to the sand, while others are nestled into lush gardens for a bit more privacy.
The on-site restaurant, Latitudes, serves up fresh seafood and locally inspired dishes with an oceanfront view that, in some respects, almost feels too perfect.
As for amenities, the property has a full-service spa, a beautiful swimming pool, and concierge services that can arrange everything from paddleboarding sessions to private boat charters.
All of these exclusive amenities makes it the best resort in Key West with beach access for those who want to splurge on their next vacation.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
1. The Mansion On The Sea – Top Overall
Google Reviews Score: 4.6 out of 5.0
Key Highlights:
- Historic oceanfront estate with direct water access
- Highly personalized service in an intimate setting
- Luxurious suites with private balconies overlooking the sea
After all the analysis, we conclude that The Mansion On The Sea is the best resort in Key West on the beach.
This timeless property makes you feel like you’ve stepped into a completely different era—one where attention to detail, personalized service, and old-world elegance still matter.
Unlike sprawling resorts with hundreds of rooms, this estate-style property is more intimate, offering an experience that’s far more exclusive than anything else on this list.
The beachfront location is literally steps away and the atmosphere is about as private as it gets. The entire space is designed to feel like a refined escape, with classic architectural details, finely curated furnishings, and a quiet, almost serene energy that’s rare to find.
Reviews & Latest Price on TripAdvisor
