The 8 Best Beach Resorts in New York 2025 | Right on the Sand

We analyzed every property on the sand and found the best beach resorts in New York that offer direct access to the water for a relaxing getaway.

We even made sure to find options all across New York State, so while most are beach resorts near New York City, we included retreats in Upstate New York as well.

When it comes to picking a beach resort in New York, the options are way more impressive than you might initially guess.

It’s almost overwhelming, in a good way, because there’s something for every type of traveler—whether you’re dreaming of luxury indulgences, a quick weekend refresh, or a family trip packed with sandcastle-building afternoons and beach barbecues.

So, if you’re wondering where to head for your next sunny escape, we pulled together a curated ranking of the best options—ranging from luxury beach resorts in New York to top-value picks perfect for beach getaways close to NYC, including Rockaway Beach, Fire Island, The Hamptons, Greenport, and Montauk.

Methodology

For this ranking of the best beach resorts New York has to offer, we carefully analyzed guest ratings and reviews from TripAdvisor, Expedia, and Google Reviews.

We compared beach access, property amenities, dining, pools, and room options. Additionally, we stayed focused on finding luxury beach resorts in New York and top-value retreats that are not only amazing, but actually worth your travel time and money.

The 8 Best New York Beach Resorts – 2025 Guide

8. Marram

See Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Location: Montauk, New York
Key Highlights:

• Direct beach access on Montauk’s south shore
• Ocean-facing rooms and suites featuring natural, earthy décor
• Outdoor heated pool with beachfront views

The Marram really brings a peaceful, chic luxury vibe that’s extremely hard to beat.

As a matter of fact, it’s a top choice for travelers looking for authentic New York beach resorts with immediate sandy access.

Rooms come in calming tones, often outfitted with Frette linens and Malin + Goetz toiletries, which makes your stay feel just a little more pampered.

For families and couples alike, there’s plenty to do, as you’re practically steps away from Montauk’s hiking trails, too.

Meanwhile, the heated oceanfront pool offers a relaxing alternative when the Atlantic feels a bit too brisk. Foodies won’t be disappointed either; Mostrador Marram serves up delicious seasonal fare that is almost too good to miss.

In short, when it comes to NYC beach resorts options, Marram is a phenomenal pick.

7. The Lodges at Cresthaven – Most Affordable

See Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Location: Lake George, New York
Key Highlights:

• Private beach on Lake George with indoor/outdoor pool complex
• 56 luxury lodges with kitchens and fireplaces
• One of the most budget-friendly beach resorts close to New York

If you’re looking for a beach resort in New York that won’t drain your entire bank account, The Lodges at Cresthaven could be exactly what you’re after.

Their beautiful wood-accented lodges offer tons of space, including kitchens for those who prefer a cozy night cooking. You’re right on the shores of Lake George, which honestly feels more like a serene oceanfront escape in many moments.

Kids typically love the playground and beachfront volleyball, while parents, frankly, might find themselves blissfully parked at the lakeside bar.

The Boathouse Restaurant, located right on-site, is perfect for local seafood lovers, too. When it comes to NY beach resorts that don’t crush your budget, this one is hard to ignore.

6. The Rockaway Hotel

See Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Location: Rockaway Beach, New York
Key Highlights:

• Just a block from Rockaway Beach’s sand and surf
• Spacious and chic rooms and suites with a rooftop pool
• On-site spa and lively beach club

If you’re looking for the best beach resorts close to New York City without needing a full weekend trip, The Rockaway Hotel really delivers something exceptional.

It’s almost effortless to get there from downtown Manhattan, with beach vibes kicking in nearly the moment you arrive. Guest rooms are sleek and airy, often featuring pastel pops of color that mirror the fun atmosphere outside.

The rooftop pool alone deserves a major shoutout, offering panoramic views that are pretty much tailor-made for Instagram.

Dining here is, frankly, a major win, with options like Margie’s serving up New American classics that even picky eaters tend to love. When it comes to finding NYC beach resorts that mix convenience and luxury, The Rockaway Hotel should be on your radar as it is truly the closest and best beach resorts in New York for those coming from the city.

5. The Madison Fire Island Pines

See Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Location: Fire Island Pines, New York
Key Highlights:

• Minutes from Fire Island’s stunning beaches
• 32 guest rooms with serene coastal décor
• Secluded pool and spa garden

If you’re all about privacy and an adults-only energy, The Madison Fire Island Pines could be exactly what your soul needs.

Located in the heart of Fire Island Pines, it’s actually just steps away from some of the most beautiful sandy shores anywhere around New York. Rooms are chic yet comforting, while also being spacious.

The property’s outdoor pool and spa garden are low-key but totally charming. Breakfast is complimentary — which, frankly, feels like a small luxury when you’re starting your morning in paradise.

As a matter of fact, this beach resort in New York is very well-known for welcoming all members of the community, making it a very inclusive, vibrant place to stay.

4. Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa – Best-Seller

See Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Location: Montauk, New York
Key Highlights:

• Private 2,000-foot stretch of Montauk beachfront
• Upgraded spa with a seawater pool
• High-end rooms, suites, and beachfront cottages

Honestly, few New York beach resorts can compete with Gurney’s when it comes to sheer popularity and luxury.

It’s virtually impossible to beat its private, wide-open beach combined with a five-star spa that actually uses ocean water in its treatments. These extra amenities also makes it easy to understand why it’s one of the most booked beach resorts NY has to offer.

Every room tends to feel like a fresh breath of coastal air, blending upscale touches with soothing décor. Dining ranges from casual bites to very polished seafood feasts at Scarpetta Beach.

Among luxury beach resorts in New York, Gurney’s Montauk has built a stellar reputation for very good reasons.

3. Hotel Moraine

See Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Location: Greenport, New York
Key Highlights:

• Luxury boutique resort right on Long Island Sound
• Just 24 rooms with private terraces and water views
• Infinity pool overlooking the beach

Unlike some other beach resorts near New York City, Hotel Moraine offers something a little bit more reserved, more understated, and incredibly elegant.

Nestled quietly in Greenport, it boasts gorgeous water views without ever feeling overwhelming or pretentious. Rooms come decked out in beach-chic styles, typically offering balconies where sunsets are nothing short of spectacular.

The infinity pool here might just be the best spot in the house, giving guests a place to unwind that’s absolutely cinematic. Dining is upscale but casual, with the menu focusing heavily on local seafood, naturally.

For travelers wanting an intimate, high-end escape at a beach resort close to New York, Hotel Moraine checks all the right boxes.

2. Ocean Resort Inn – Top Value Pick

See Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Location: Montauk, New York
Key Highlights:

• Direct beach access across the street
• Coastal-themed rooms with kitchenettes
• Refreshing heated outdoor pool

If you’re looking for one of the best values among all the beach resorts NY offers, the Ocean Resort Inn definitely stands out.

Located directly across from Montauk Beach, it’s extremely easy to go from your bed to the sand in under two minutes. The rooms might not be palatial, yet they’re spotless, cheerful, and practically perfect for beachgoers who value location first and foremost.

The heated outdoor pool provides a refreshing change of pace, especially when the ocean gets a bit too cold.

Free bikes are available for guests who want to explore Montauk’s low-key downtown vibe.

For beach getaways close to NYC where you can still save some money for seafood feasts and sunset cocktails, Ocean Resort Inn is pretty much a dream scenario.

1. Hero Beach Club – Top Overall

See Location & Prices: Check on Google Maps
Location: Montauk, New York
Key Highlights:

• Just steps from Kirk Park Beach
• Modern and upscale rooms and suites
• Outdoor pool, meditation garden, and fire pits

Hero Beach Club, in short, wins top honors as the best beach resort in New York because it masters every detail and offers exactly what you want from a beach resort.

Located right next to the wide sands of Kirk Park Beach, it offers travelers an effortless beach resort experience near New York. Rooms combine cool modern design with very chill coastal tones, making it a joy to wake up each morning.

The property’s amenities are all about outdoor living, from the refreshing pool to the cozy evening fire pits that practically demand a s’mores session.

Dining options are casual but tasty, and nearby Montauk hotspots are incredibly easy to reach. Basically, if you want the ultimate beach getaways close to NYC, Hero Beach Club could be the only call you need to make.

Articles You Might Also Like